Six Findings That Surprised Us From the Higher Ed Index
This summer, we surveyed over 12,000 Americans. Six findings surprised us.
If you work in higher ed, you’ve read this year’s headlines about falling public trust. So has your board. The headlines aren’t wrong. They’re thin. They tell you what’s happening nationally, but not why, for which audience, or for your market.
That’s the gap the Higher Ed Index was built to close. This summer we surveyed 12,247 Americans ages 16 and up, from all 50 states and DC, and put the general public, prospective students, parents, college students, alumni and adult learners side by side on the same questions. Six findings surprised us.
1. The belief cliff hits in senior year of high school.
Admissions teams treat senior year as the euphoric one. (Count the exclamation points in your next email to seniors.) The Index disagrees. Compared with rising juniors, rising seniors score lower on every belief we asked about, by 6 to 17 points.
Seniors believe less than juniors
Some of the drop is growing up, since seniors trust every institution in the survey less than juniors do. But that 17-point gap on ads is ours to own. Cost is the likely accelerant. Half of seniors name it the most significant issue facing colleges, up from 1 in 3 juniors.
For students who aren’t planning on college, half say college is out of reach for them. Yet only 29% name cost as the biggest issue, compared with 42% of their college-bound peers. Two-thirds are young men, and nearly half would be the first in their family to attend. What they doubt is whether college is for someone like them.
The takeaway: Senior year is when students start learning what we’re actually like. How authentic is the messaging they’re getting?
2. College seniors recommend college less than any group before them.
We used Net Promoter Score to track likelihood to recommend a four-year college or university across the journey. First-year students are the most enthusiastic group in the survey, at +54. By senior year of college, it’s +33. That 21-point slide happens while students are on campus with us.
Likelihood to recommend a four-year college or university, by stage
The takeaway: Current students aren’t usually a marketing audience, but they’re where word of mouth starts. Marketing and student affairs need to tell the story students are actually living.
3. Women in college trust it less than men do.
Before college, women trust colleges at least as much as men do: 65% of prospective women versus 59% of prospective men, a difference that isn’t statistically significant. Among college students, a 13-point gap opens the other way, and among alumni it’s 10 points. Men’s trust barely moves. Women’s falls. The gap holds among Democrats and Republicans alike.
Women haven’t given up on college, though. Their likelihood to recommend is statistically the same as men’s, and they’re 18 points less likely than men to blame their college when graduates can’t find jobs.
The takeaway: Women want support while they’re enrolled: academic services, a safe campus, internships, and professors who know them. Do your campus’s support services reflect these needs?
4. Cost doesn’t separate skeptics from advocates. Worth does.
Nearly half of Americans, 47%, name cost as higher ed’s top issue. That’s exactly why it tells you so little. What separates advocates from skeptics is whether the cost is worth it. People who say it’s worth it give four-year colleges an NPS of +47. People who say it isn’t give them −40.
There are four beliefs an institution can influence to drive worth: college prepares people to adapt as careers change, colleges reflect my values, colleges are truthful in how they present themselves, and college is worth it even when cheaper options exist.
The takeaway: Worth is a career and credibility judgment. How often does cost stand in as the excuse?
5. Americans aren’t asking for a three-year bachelor’s degree yet.
More than 100 shorter bachelor’s programs have appeared across 25 states since 2025. The public isn’t sold. Four years is still the most common answer for how long a degree should take, from 39% of parents to 58% of alumni. Parents are split by their own educational experience: 57% of parents with a bachelor’s degree want four years, compared with 32% of those without.
Yet two in three Americans say a graduate with an accelerated two-year degree is just as prepared for work.
The takeaway: If four years doesn’t make a better-prepared worker, the extra years have to prove value through the experience.
6. Most Americans say trade school sets people up as well as a four-year degree.
87% of Americans say trade or vocational school sets someone up for success as well as or better than a four-year degree. It’s the only alternative where more people say better than worse, 35% to 13%. Grouped with community college, that pathway out-recommends the four-year college with the general public, parents, adult learners, and alumni. Only prospective students clearly prefer the four-year degree.
Free tuition doesn’t explain it. People in states with free community college rate that pathway better at about the same rate as everyone else, 40% compared with 41%. Speed doesn’t either. What the data points to is preparedness. People can see the line from the program to the job.
The takeaway: Show the through-line. Saying a degree “builds skills” isn’t the same as showing which skills lead to which jobs.
Curious? Good.
These six findings are the headline. The full report has every data point behind them, and more of what we think they mean.
![]()
These discoveries are national, and none of them tell you how your institution reads in your own markets. The Higher Ed Index can, with results by state, region, and audience, so the next decision your team makes is backed by data on your own markets, not by the latest headlines.
Tell us what you want to know about your markets, and we’ll show you what the Higher Ed Index can answer.
Read Our Thoughts
-
How Higher Education Grew and Why Public Trust Declined in the Process
By Jason Simon
March 11, 2026 • 3 min read -
AI-Driven Discovery is not Dismantling Brand Experience. It’s Making it More Honest.
By Dayana Kibilds
July 8, 2026 • 3 min read -
Marketing Can't Fix What Leadership Won't Face
By Jason Simon
February 5, 2026